I read through the entire thread, and came to the conclusion that ninneviane is simply an asshole, one of a particularly obnoxious variety who equates verbage with wisdom. I could hardly read her comments, my bullshit detector was going off so loudly!
I gave it the good ol' college try. I wonder what she'd say if she re-read the thread in ten years or so. The best by far was long before I showed up: the complete evaluation of Mary's psyche from a statement that she prefers no spoilers. Yow!
no subject
no subject